Menu Close

Top Ten Tuesday: Characters I Just Didn’t Click With

It’s Top Ten Tuesday again, hosted by The Broke and The Bookish! This week it’s the top ten characters I just didn’t click with. All book covers from Goodreads.

Ten Characters I Just Didn’t Click With

1. Holden Caulfield from The Catcher in the Rye

catcher-in-the-rye

I read this during the height of my teenage angst and I STILL found him annoying.

 

2. Charlie from The Perks of Being a Wallflower

perks-wallflower

Oh boy…I’m not gonna make any friends from putting this one on my list (I’ll probably make some enemies). Like Catcher in the Rye, I read this during a time when I thought it would be especially relevant to my life, but didn’t really connect to it all that much.

 

3. Sean, Lauren, and Paul from The Rules of Attraction

rules-attraction

I REALLY enjoyed the movie adaptation, which I watched as a freshman in a college similar to the one that the novel takes place in. So I was disappointed when I didn’t enjoy the book nearly as much as the movie. Although the characters probably aren’t meant to be very likable because they’re arrogant, shallow college students, I preferred their movie counterparts over those in the book.

 

4. Katniss from The Hunger Games

hunger-games

Probably part of the reason why I was never able to latch onto the craze surrounding this series.

 

5. Ceony from The Paper Magician

the-paper-magician

Although I enjoyed the overall setting of this novel, not liking the protagonist made it difficult for me to finish.

 

6. Jane Eyre from…Jane Eyre

jane-eyre

One of those books I was assigned to read for school and probably wouldn’t have finished otherwise.

 

7. Marianne and Elinor from Sense and Sensibility

sense-sensibility

See Jane Eyre.

 

8. Ann and Adele from Anywhere But Here

anywhere-but-here

Another case where I liked preferred the characters in the movie adaptation more than the source material.

 

9. Sookie Stackhouse from Dead Until Dark

dead-until-dark

I was never a huge fan of True Blood so I can’t really compare her character in the book versus the show.

10. John from The Contortionist’s Handbook

contortionists-handbook

I thought the book had an intriguing premise, but I didn’t care much for John.

 

I find that an unlikable protagonist or one that I have a hard time relating to (especially if the story is told through first person) can really taint my perception of a book, even if the overall story is good. However, I think it’s also possible to not like the protagonist as a person (perhaps they’re evil or more of an anti-hero) but still be intrigued enough by what’s happening to them to keep turning the page. Sometimes I have difficulty connecting with characters because they’re flat or cookie-cutter personas. Other times, it’s through no fault of the authors writing – just as you’re not best friends with everyone you’ve ever met, I’ve also found that there are some fictional characters that I just don’t get along with.

Have you ever had similar experiences with a fictional character?


Liked this post? Feel free to share! 

16 Comments

  1. Sumaya

    I can totally relate with Catcher in the Rye! I hated reading in Holden’s POV! You think it would help you sympathize with a character; it just made me hate him more!

    • Zed Amadeo

      I thought, since the book is a classic, that I would be the only one who felt that way about Holden. Instead, almost everyone I know that has read that book has told me that they felt similarly irritated by him.

  2. Kristen Burns

    Don’t worry, I’m not gonna make any friends with some of my choices either, haha. I also included Katniss in my list, even though so many people love her. And I can understand why you included Ceony. My love of Emery carried me through the series, but I was annoyed with Ceony’s actions in the the second and third books.

    • Zed Amadeo

      I preferred Emery’s far more than Ceony and enjoyed learning more about his backstory in the first book. I also really liked the magic system and the world of The Paper Magician. I think that it could have been a book that I really loved if it had a different protagonist.

    • Zed Amadeo

      I got almost 3/4 through Jane Eyre before I just couldn’t force myself to read it anymore. I got an audiobook so I could listen to it while doing other stuff. When I showed up to English class, it turned out that I was the only one who had actually finished it on time!

    • Zed Amadeo

      Not caring about Jane made it realllyyyy difficult for me to get through that book. If it hadn’t been assigned by my English class, I probably wouldn’t have even finished it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.